For over 50 years, we, at Attic Door Furniture, have been dedicated to selling home furnishings on consignment. Located in the tranquil hamlet of Oyster Bay, we are proud to carry on the tradition of excellence in customer service that began with our grandmother in 1969 and was carried on by our parents, Bruce and Jean Tiberio, for decades. Today, Attic Door Furniture stands as one of the oldest and most successful consignment shops on Long Island's North Shore.Throughout our decades of sales service, Attic Door Furniture has been renowned for the high quality, ever-changing inventory of furniture and decorative home accessories that fill the store.
Follow us
Services
During this time of uncertainty, when the idea of having a tag sale or connecting with random strangers via Craig's List, Facebook Market or EBay may not feel comfortable, you want the reliability knowledge, experience and trusted expertise that comes with our family name. Choosing to consign with us is a safe, socially responsible and environmentally friendly way to turn your home furnishings into money in your pocket. We only bring highly sought after furniture, artwork, and decorative accessories into our store.
Who determines the price? We leverage our knowledge, experience and expertise having been in the furniture business for over 50 years to set prices that are competitive for our clients and a great deal for our shoppers. We offer free appraisals where we will discuss the selling price. We reserve the right to mark pieces at the price that we believe will make for a mutually advantageous sale with the belief in mind that we are working for you.
Reviews (9)
Bill Albert
Apr 12, 2022
Mr. O.
Dec 06, 2021
Madeleine Giraldi
Oct 09, 2021
Robbie R.
May 24, 2020
Tc Schmidt
Feb 16, 2019
Arlene Crandall
Nov 29, 2018
Heather Benazzi
May 27, 2016
You can always count on Attic Door for a special piece that you were either looking for, or didn't know you were looking for until you found it there. I bought the perfect coffee table there, and a gorgeous hutch made in England for amazing prices. When my Grandmother passed away, they seamlessly took pieces from the home and were very easy to work with. They are very helpful and delightful to work with at Attic Door. You'd better get over there because their turnover is quick!
Ann B.
Apr 11, 2016
I have had nothing but great experiences with the Attic Door Furniture. I have consigned with them several times and they have ALWAYS been honest with me when my items have sold. They provide their consigners with a list of items that sold and how much each item sold for. They also do free pick ups which is awesome and convenient. Their prices are extremely reasonable hence why they have such a quick turnover and their items are always so beautiful. I definitely recommend them!
Efstratios Sourlis
May 31, 2015
When I contacted them, I believe it was the owner who I spoke with, didn't sound very interested from the get go. He asked me a couple of questions about the furniture then said he didn't think it was anything he would be interested in, but send HIM pictures which I did. Now according to their write up, they said they come to your house and evaluate the items.
I'm in Plainview maybe 15 miles away, They couldn't just drop by and look? I received an email after he saw the pictures again he said it did not seem like anything he wanted but indicated he would take a look. I haven't heard from him since. I left 2 messages with the receptionist because he was out when I called to ask when he was coming, neither was returned. My impression of Attic Door is not good at all, hence this review.
I'm in Plainview maybe 15 miles away, They couldn't just drop by and look? I received an email after he saw the pictures again he said it did not seem like anything he wanted but indicated he would take a look. I haven't heard from him since. I left 2 messages with the receptionist because he was out when I called to ask when he was coming, neither was returned. My impression of Attic Door is not good at all, hence this review.
